
Planning Your Move
Italian Citizenship Law Changed. What Should You Do While the Courts Decide?
The 2025 Italian citizenship changes disrupted many family plans. Jennifer explains what can be prepared responsibly while legal challenges and individual eligibility remain unresolved.
November 17, 2026
By Jennifer Sontag | Founder, ViaMonde
I keep speaking with families who feel as if someone has pulled the rug out from under their Italian citizenship plans.
They've spent years talking about their grandparents, tracing records, researching towns, and imagining what living in Italy might look like. Then the law changes, litigation begins, and the question becomes: Do we stop everything until the courts tell us what happens next?
I understand the temptation to put the whole project in a drawer. But I wouldn't confuse uncertainty about the outcome with having nothing useful to do.
What changed in 2025?
Italy's Decree-Law 36/2025, converted into Law 74/2025, substantially changed recognition of citizenship by descent for many people born abroad who also possess another citizenship. The new Article 3-bis establishes limitations and exceptions, including circumstances tied to a parent's or grandparent's citizenship and certain earlier applications or confirmed appointments.
The details are not interchangeable. The date and manner of an earlier application may matter. So may an ancestor's naturalization history, whether an applicant qualifies under a particular statutory exception, and whether a claim involves a court rather than an administrative procedure.
It's therefore risky to assume that everyone in a family is eligible—or ineligible—for exactly the same reason.
A family isn't always one case
One family we worked with was considering whether a mother and her adult children might need different approaches under the changed rules. Their ancestral history included important naturalization dates, but the adults in different generations were not necessarily situated alike under the current framework.
The useful decision wasn't 'Should we file everyone immediately?' It was to review the line and each person's circumstances separately, then ask our legal team which options, if any, actually remained open.
That distinction can save a family from spending thousands on the wrong documents or pursuing a route that doesn't fit the law as it stands.
What can you responsibly do while litigation continues?
Start with an eligibility review, not an assumption that a favorable court ruling is inevitable. We cannot promise that a challenge will succeed or that any future ruling will apply to your circumstances.
If there is a potentially viable route, get serious about the record: births, marriages, deaths, naturalization documents, and records that connect each generation. Review name discrepancies, missing entries, translations, apostilles, and what needs correction. Some records take months to obtain, and a seemingly small inconsistency can become a substantial delay later.
But don't automatically order every document for every family member before the legal theory is clear. There is a balance between being prepared and spending money on a claim with no supported route.
If your plans also include living in Italy, keep those decisions moving on their own track. Learn Italian. Consider a scouting stay. Investigate what housing and tax residence would mean. You may decide to pursue an immigration pathway independent of citizenship—or to wait without giving up on the idea of Italy.
What are we doing at ViaMonde?
Our attorneys have been contributing to legal work at the EU Court of Justice, the Constitutional Court and the Court of Cassation concerning the citizenship framework and following the regional court decisions. That work matters, but it doesn't give us a crystal ball. I would rather tell a family the legal situation is unresolved than present an advocacy effort or referral to a higher court as a victory.
The practical thing we can offer is judgment: Which facts matter? Where is the documentation weak? Which application or court route, if any, is defensible under today's law? What should be done now, and what is better deferred?
That's not always the answer people want. It's the answer I think they deserve.
Are the 2025 citizenship restrictions already overturned?
Do not assume that litigation or a court referral has invalidated the law. Check the current legal position and any published decisions with qualified Italian counsel before taking action.
Should I gather documents before knowing whether I qualify?
A preliminary review of family lineage and naturalization records is often useful. More expensive document collection, translations, corrections, and filing should follow a case-specific eligibility assessment.
If your family paused a citizenship application after the 2025 reform, ViaMonde can review your facts and discuss what steps are supported now, what remains uncertain, and what preparation might be sensible. This article is informational, not a prediction of a court outcome.